patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Results of Acton Senior Center Survey

Although not many Acton seniors responded to the Council on Aging's survey, the Senior Center Building Committee sees a real need for a new, bigger senior/community center.

 

A survey of Acton seniors about the need for a new senior center brought a tepid response.

The Council on Aging (COA) and the Senior Center Building Committee (SCBC) released the results of a January survey of Acton seniors. The COA sent the survey out in its newsletter to 2,000 homes, and also conducted an online survey and distributed hard copies at the center.

While the 2011 census puts Acton's senior population at 3,900, just 194 people responded to the survey.

“If you assume that all of the town seniors actually got it, which I don’t think you can assume, it represents a response rate of about 5 percent,” said Peter Ashton, SCBC chair. “The initial reaction is that the results are really low but actually when you do surveys, if you get a response rate of anything 5 percent or higher, that is actually not a bad response rate.”

Survey Results (see attachment for full survey):

  • 70 seniors said they use the senior center weekly, 46 seniors said they only attend for certain programs, and 32 said they never attend.
  • 36 seniors said they utilize the Council on Aging's information/referrals services, 29 seniors said they utilize the borrowing of medical equipment services, and 27 seniors said they utilize the health insurance counseling service.
  • The vast majority of seniors said they use the senior center mostly during the morning and early afternoon hours.
  • The most popular programs seniors said they would take part in are: 

91 said history presentation

81 said strength training

73 said music appreciation

66 said movies

61 said balance training

  • 149 seniors said they would be willing to pay $1-to-$5 to attend classes at the senior center, 13 said they would but it would be financially tough, and 28 said they would not pay.
  • 48 seniors said they would support Acton building a new senior/community center, 37 seniors said they would support a building that was only a senior center, and 46 seniors said they did not have enough information to respond.

According to COA Senior Center Executive Director Sharon Mercurio, the current center is quite small to be able to conduct the activities the COA would like to undergo.

“Right now we really don’t have a place for folks to just drop in—we have a dining room but it's being used in so many different ways that if you just want to meet a friend and have a cup of coffee there is not a consistent place to do that,” said Mercurio. “We have wellness clinics and podiatry clinics but that all has to happen in the dining room when there are art classes going on and lunches being made. So if someone has a sensitive issue that they want to talk to the nurse about in private they are kind of in the middle of chaos.”

The 2010 Census had the Acton senior population at 3,700 and the 2011 Census had the Acton senior population up to 3,900 – a 5 percent increase in one year. The SCBC estimated that by the year 2030 the Acton senior population would be 6,000.

According to Allen Nitschelm, publisher of the Acton Forum, Acton does not need a new senior/community center because there is not enough evidence to show that the current center is not big enough. Nitschelm conducted his own study of how many cars were parked at the senior center by visiting the center 30 times at different times of the day during the months of June/July 2011. He said that the average number of cars in the parking lot at any one time: 12.

Nitschelm is also concerned about the cost of the project. According to his latest blog entry on the Acton Forum, “The fact is that Acton has a very large unfunded healthcare liability called OPEB which it is not planning to fund at an adequate level next year. We should not be taking on further debt and expenses when we aren't meeting our current obligations.”

The total estimated cost would be somewhere between $.7.7 million, with an estimated annual debt service of $500,000 a year (estimated $70 a year on the average tax bill) - with an additional operating cost for personnel and supplies of $270,000.

The SCBC plans to request $140,000 at Town Meeting on April 2 for a design budget, with a final construction amount by April 2014.

The SCBC will hold an informational public meeting at 7 p.m. Monday
in the Faulkner room of Acton Town Hall. The community needs to help define what a senior/community center is. The SCBC has been kicking around ideas of what part the community center aspect would play at a senior center. They came up with uses such as:

  • Swimming pool
  • Youth center
  • Gym
  • Meeting space (outside rental usage)
  • Afternoon/Evening usage
  • Day care
Related Topics: Acton Senior Center, Community Center, Council On Aging, Senior Center, and Senior Center Building Committee

Allen Nitschelm

6:35 am on Friday, February 10, 2012

Nice overview, Patrick!

The issue of usage is most important. The 2009 study looked at "peak usage" (i.e., when the parking lot was full) and that was the only data presented. Back then, they found 23 times over eight weeks when the parking lot was full.

Using the same metric in 2011, they conducted two studies. In the spring, they measured parking lot usage for 6 weeks and found no instances of it being full. (They had added 4 or 5 parking spaces in the interim, so if you use the same number of spaces to compare, there were 5 instances where it would have been full.)

Likewise, in the Fall 2011 study, they found only 5 times in 7 weeks when parking was full (10 if you use the same number of spaces in 2008). Both studies are on Acton Forum.

This "peak usage" methodology, which is how they chose to demonstrate that the Senior Center was overcrowded in 2009, shows that it is not in 2011.

I'm not arguing that we should never build a new Senior Center. I'm saying that we need some evidence that the current center is too busy, and that evidence shows peak usage going down (even as the senior population goes up). So something else is going on. Until we know what that is, it makes no sense to proceed.

Allen

Reply

Paul Henrion (Acton Community Leading Initiatives

1:32 pm on Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Excellent and helpful comments from Patrick and Allen. My concerns are different:

* What results on transportation obstacles? A center w/ no cars in the lot might be a good thing.
* Desire for job training?
* Desire for work space w/ tech support to enable remote employment w/ job sharing (time, skills, illness, etc.)
* Desire to do community service work rather than being the recipient of?
* Does everyone agree that Education/support isn't just for the young, that everyone needs it?

When we voted to fund a community services coordinator, we didn't require every person in Acton needing service to tell us what they needed. We knew it. All the other well run Towns had been doing it for decades. If incredibly smart people like the world class leaders at Council on Aging, Senior Ctr Mgt, and their leading supporters like Paulina Knibbe, Steve and Bernice Baran, think we need expanded facilities and services, that's good enough for me.

Time to do it again. Time to give seniors the support we got from them when they raised the rest of us. Determining the exact best activities for any year will be ongoing forever. With our leaders the "what" will be a world class solution just like the CSC. See you at Town Mtg. Bring your fellow workers, friends, congregants and neighbors. We need votes, not more analysis.

Respectfully,
Paul Henrion for ACLI
See ACLI on facebook http://www.facebook.com/pages/Acton-Community-Leading-Initiatives/224227354327760

Reply

Leave a comment